We Don’t Have Kings: Why the Trump Tariff Ruling Is Bigger Than Trade

Published by: The Center PartySlogan: Common Sense. Common Ground.

No Kings Logo

A Legal Defeat with Larger Meaning

In a striking legal decision this week, a U.S. federal appeals court ruled that most of former President Donald Trump’s global tariffs were illegal, declaring that the president overstepped the boundaries of executive power. Specifically, the court found that Trump’s use of national emergency authority did not grant him the right to unilaterally impose taxes or duties on imports.

This decision is more than a policy reversal — it’s a constitutional check on unchecked power, and a warning flare for Americans across the political spectrum: if we accept power grabs just because we agree with the outcome, we open the door for abuses we’ll regret later.

What Did the Court Say?

The ruling centered around the statutory limits of the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA), a law that gives the president sweeping authority to respond to foreign threats or crises. Trump invoked this law to justify tariffs against countries like China, Canada, and several EU nations.

But the court said plainly:

“The statute bestows significant authority on the President... but none of these actions explicitly include the power to impose tariffs, duties, or the like, or the power to tax.”

Translation? Even in an emergency, the president can’t act like a one-man legislature.

What Were the Tariffs, and Why Do They Matter?

The tariffs were part of Trump's aggressive approach to trade — a key pillar of his presidency. Steel, aluminum, and other goods were targeted globally. His rationale? National security and unfair trade practices.

But here's the problem:

• These tariffs disrupted global supply chains.

• They led to retaliatory tariffs against U.S. farmers and manufacturers.

• And now we know — they weren’t legally authorized in the first place.

Even if you agree with the idea of tougher trade rules, the method matters. Presidential power isn’t a loophole. It’s a responsibility with limits.

A Reminder from the Constitution

America’s founders feared concentrated power. That’s why the Constitution gave Congress — not the president — the power to levy taxes and regulate trade.

Why? Because Congress is accountable to you — the voters. When a president can override that, we inch closer to monarchy than democracy.

The court’s decision reaffirms what’s supposed to be obvious:

The law is not whatever the president says it is.

This isn’t just a Trump issue. It's a constitutional principle. Today, it's tariffs. Tomorrow, it could be surveillance, censorship, or worse. No president — left, right, or center — should be allowed to govern without guardrails.

When Presidents Push Too Far

Trump isn’t the first to test the limits of executive power. Presidents from both parties have used emergency declarations for policy ends:

• FDR interned Japanese Americans during WWII.

• Bush and Obama expanded surveillance under national security umbrellas.

• Biden used executive action to cancel student loan debt (until the Supreme Court ruled it exceeded his authority).

• Now Trump used emergency powers to implement a global tax plan.

Each of these examples — even if done with good intent — should make us pause.

When power isn’t checked, it eventually gets abused.

The Center Party Lion Logo

What the Center Party Believes

The Center Party isn’t here to play team sports with our democracy. We’re here to rebuild trust, enforce common sense boundaries, and bring this country back to a place where the rules apply to everyone — especially those in power.

We believe in:

• Clear limits on presidential authority

• Congressional responsibility for taxation and trade

• Guardrails that prevent unilateral economic disruption

• Constitutional clarity over partisan chaos

We’ll work with Democrats when they’re right. We’ll work with Republicans when they’re right. But we’ll call out overreach from either side. Always.

What Comes Next?

The decision doesn’t automatically undo every tariff — it’s still being appealed, and global trade negotiations are in flux. But it sends a message:

You don’t get to declare an emergency and skip the process. You don’t get to legislate by press conference. You don’t get to bypass Congress because it’s inconvenient.

And most of all?

You don’t get to act like a king in a constitutional democracy.

Final Thought: Don’t Cheer for Power — Demand Accountability

Some will shrug this off. Others will cheer because they dislike Trump. But the bigger question is: What kind of country do we want to live in?

If we cheer for unchecked power when “our side” is in charge, we set the stage for disaster when it’s not. The law must be durable. The Constitution must be respected. And power must be earned, not seized.

This ruling is a win — not for any one party, but for the idea that no one is above the law.

Common Sense. Common Ground. A government that works — because it plays by the rules.— The Center Party